Islamic marriage advice and family advice

Confused Sibling Marriage

Confused

Dear Bilqis saab, Salaam Valaikum,

This in regards to marriage about a sibling I love most. This sibling uterus sister and has shared the same womb. The girl was born by zinah and I was taken as a child and have shared no milk from my mother even once as I was adopted by a well to do family.

I have married this girl who was born by zinah and we have a child now. There are lot of eyebrows raised. Are we allowed to live with this marriage or reconsider this proposal. We love each other so much n pray not to circumspect suicide in life.

(A) Share same womb
(B) Girl born by zinah
(C) No milk suckling
(D) Seperate Fostering

Regards,
Sohail khan


Tagged as: , , , , ,

2 Responses »

  1. AA;

    How do you know she is your sister? And if every body knows you are siblings, how did they let you get married?
    With that, you CANNOT marry your sister no matter what the circumstances are!!!

    No need to talk suicide and go to extream measures. Inshallah ALLAH will provide the best solution to all.

    If I am correct, it is from ALLAH. If I err it is from me, and I pray ALLAH forgives me.

    AA.

    Just a Man

  2. Salaams,

    Brother, regardless of whether you grew up with your sister or nursed, or how she was born, if you have the same mother she is haraam to you. Being born "out of zinaa" does not negate the blood relationship. "Not nursing" does not negate the blood relationship. Not growing up in the same household does not negate the blood relationship. In this case, sharing the same womb trumps everything else, and in order to return the relationship of brother/sister back to it's natural status it would mean ending the marriage.

    -Amy
    IslamicAnswers.com Editor

Leave a Response