Islamic marriage advice and family advice

They did istikhaarah without our knowledge and it was negative

hijabi sister

well im troubled and depressed and Ive been looking for answers and solutions  except i dont know who to ask and who not to ask since every ones got a different answer and solution. I've known this guy for 4 years and we've been together ever since, we've had problems related to his family his mother had an issue with me since I was an outsider and not part of the family, hes a syed shiah and I belong to a syed sunni family. There were issues like that but we moved past a of them, before any obstacles came in the way I wasn't very religious nor spirtiual to the extent that I am now. I started feeling very close to God and I've never been the kind of person who gets attached towards a lot of people, I've got a very few people in my life I care about and for that matter love. I don't even consider having best friends or anything as I believe only Allah is my best friend. I've been a loner from the beginning and have always liked solitude and quietness.

Anyway we have had so many obstacles in the way and ALLAH helped me out, time and time again and his mother started to accept me and then his dad also got to know and he told her to meet me and my family. His mother was all ready to meet my family and me and that I was happy everything was so nice and we didnt even know until the guys dad got an istikhara done. It's called quranic istikhara he got it done from someone and we didnt even know about it. It came out bad.
I dont even know what to do I'm so depressed I have so many questions in my head and so many things I dont know if I should do or not

Let me begin with my first question: this is my understanding that istikhara is done when ur not sure about something like you've just begun to talk to someone we've known each other for 4 years I wasnt even prepared for this! but hey we didnt do it? neither did I nor did the guy do it, he wasnt even aware. Even hes so sad and depressed about what they did without us knowing.

Secondly i believe a person should do it himself! Not a third person doing it for somone else, like we pray and ask ALLAH for whatever that we want, similarly my heart says that a person should be in direct contact with him and talk to him directly even for an answer.

Thirdly what I want to know is if from one side the istikhara is bad and the other side it is good? what does that mean does it mean its neutral?

Also another question suppose if the istikhara is bad is there any solution for that? for betterment of two peoples futures?

let me also repeat that i didnt do any istikhara neither did the guy. it was his family who got it done from someone some imam i guess.

now im left with no choice but to do it myself in order to know the truth and in order to make things better so we can get married in the future. im not prepared for it at all since im not a wali im an ordinary human being with feelings. and i dont expect God is cruel if we met there was a reason for it and if after all the obstacles we;v been through we stil made it and things became so much better for us and we were happy that has to mean something this is the third time something has gone wrong i mean if it had to end why didnt it some years ago. i just done feel it in my heart .

please help answer my questions and pray for me iam confused i need clarity and i need to feel better as my healt is deteriorating cz of so much tension and depression and confusion . everyone has got a different explanation theres not one person whos answer has satisfied me yet.

-Nobody


Tagged as: , , ,

2 Responses »

  1. asalamoalikum
    first of ALL dear as u said it in ur ques ur onli bestfriend is allah and we all now that allahs loves for us is more then that of 70 mothers so my first advice is pray 2 namaz tahajud tell allah ur problem in the dua and just beleive in watever the fate he desides for is going to b the best because WHAT WE WANT IS NOT ALWAYS WHAT WE AND ALLAH KNOWS THE BEST...
    for your 1st and 2ndques:astakhara can be done by any one who is close to and concerns for the person but its best if the person does it them selfs, his parent must b concerned abt their son so they did it for him just put urself in their shoes and think wat wud u in a situation if your not sure wheather ur child is making the right desicion of his live wouldnt u want to find out urself...
    3rd ques:the one who has good side of istekhara means the desicion wud be good for him nd the one who has bad side means it wud be bad for him
    istikhara just tells you that the decision ur making might have a lot of hardship and problems in the future now its up to u to go with it if u think that u got the guts to face thses problem and fight them and not be depressed or sad or ur cant handle the up coming future problems so my advice is dont risk it...
    and i always pray for all muslims may allah help all muslim in need

  2. Dear Sister, Asalaamualaykum,

    Firstly, I must remind you that pre-marital relationships are absolutely haraam. If you have engaged in any type of emotional or physical intimacy with this man, I urge you to repent to Allah. When we are facing difficulties, we must look within ourselves and assess our own behaviour - have we done anything to anger Allah(swt), have we done anything that could in anyway have contributed to the situation we are in?

    Secondly, like many people, unfortunately you have misunderstood Istikhara. Istikhara is done when we are have done our research on a matter, we have sought advice about it and we are inclined towards it - we then ask Allah(swt) to make that path easy for us if it is good for us in this life and the next and to take it away from us, if it is not good for us in this life and the next. Istikhara is not done by some old 'baba' living in the middle of no-where who has no clue who you are. You do Istikhara yourself, your 'prospective' does it, your parents can do it too as they are also part of the decision making process.

    Sister - please read these articles on Istikhara, inshaAllah they will help you:

    http://www.zawaj.com/askbilqis/salat-al-istikhara-the-guidance-prayer/istikhara-in-the-light-of-the-sunnah/

    http://www.zawaj.com/askbilqis/salat-al-istikhara-the-guidance-prayer/power-of-salat-ul-istikhara/

    http://www.zawaj.com/askbilqis/salat-al-istikhara-the-guidance-prayer/salat-al-istikhara-in-arabic/

    http://www.zawaj.com/askbilqis/salat-al-istikhara-the-guidance-prayer/salat-al-istikhara-in-urdu/
    (Show this one to your father if he reads urdu)

    http://www.zawaj.com/askbilqis/salat-al-istikhara-the-guidance-prayer/the-prayer-of-need-salat-al-hajah-or-istikhara/

    http://www.zawaj.com/askbilqis/salat-al-istikhara-the-guidance-prayer/

    ***
    Best Wishes,

    SisterZ
    IslamicAnswers.com Editor

Leave a Response